This section describes the use case scenarios present in the world of SNOMED CT and how Snow Owl can be used in those scenarios to maximize its full potential. Each scenario comes with a summary and a pros/cons section to help your decision making process when selecting the appropriate scenario for your use case.

• Single Edition

• Single Extension

• Multi Extension

Introduction

The Snow Owl Terminology Server is capable of managing multiple SNOMED CT extensions for both distribution and authoring purposes in a single deployment. This guide describes the typical scenarios, like creating, managing, releasing and upgrading SNOMED CT Extensions in great detail with images. If you are unfamiliar with SNOMED CT Extensions, the next section walks you through their logical model and basic characteristics, while the following pages describe distribution and authoring scenarios as well as how to use the Snow Owl Terminology Server for SNOMED CT Extensions.

Extensions and Snow Owl

What is a SNOMED CT Extension?

Common Structure

SNOMED CT is a multilingual clinical terminology that covers a broad scope. However, some users may need additional concepts, relationships, descriptions or reference sets to support national, local or organizational needs.

The extension mechanism allows SNOMED CT to be customized to address the terminology needs of a country or organization that are not met by the International Edition.

A SNOMED CT Extension may contain components and/or derivatives (e.g. reference sets used to represent subsets, maps or language preferences). Since the international edition and all extensions share a common structure, the same application software can be used to enter, store and process information from different extensions. Similarly, reference sets can be constructed to refer to content from both the international release and extensions. The common structure also makes it easier for content developed by an extension producer to be submitted for possible inclusion in a National Edition or the International Edition.

Therefore, a SNOMED CT Extension uses the same Release Format version 2 as the International Edition, they share a common structure and schema (see Release Format 2 specification).

Namespace

Extensions are managed by SNOMED International, and Members or Affiliate Licensees who have been issued a namespace identifier by SNOMED International. A namespace identifier is used to create globally unique SNOMED CT identifiers for each component (i.e. concept, description and relationship) within a Member or Affiliate extension. This ensures that references to extension concepts contained in health record data are unambiguous and can be clearly attributed to a specific issuing organization.

A national or local extension uses a namespace identifier issued by SNOMED International to ensure that all extension components can be uniquely identified (across all extensions).

Therefore, a SNOMED CT Extension uses a single namespace identifier to identify all core components in the SNOMED CT Extension (see Namespace identifier).

Modules

Every SNOMED CT Extension includes one or more modules, and each module contains either SNOMED CT components or reference sets (or both). Modules may be dependent on other modules. A SNOMED CT Edition includes the contents of a focus module together with the contents of all the modules on which it depends. This includes the modules in the International Edition and possibly other modules from a national and/or local extension.

An edition is defined based on a single focus module. This focus module must be the most dependent module, in that the focus module is dependent on all the other modules in the edition.

Therefore, a SNOMED CT Extension uses one or more modules to categorize the components into meaningful groups (see Modules).

Language

SNOMED CT extensions can support a variety of use cases, including:

Translating SNOMED CT, for example

• Adding terms used in a local language or dialect

• Adding terms used by a specific user group, such as patient-friendly terms

Representing language, dialect or specialty-specific term preferences is possible using a SNOMED CT extension. The logical design of SNOMED CT enables a single clinical idea to be associated with a range of terms or phrases from various languages, as depicted in Figure 3.1-1 below. In an extension, terms relevant for a particular country, speciality, hospital (or other organization) may be created, and different options for term preferences may be specified. Even within the same country, different regional dialects or specialty-specific languages exist may influence which synonyms are preferred. SNOMED CT supports this level of granularity for language preferences at the national or local level.

Therefore, an Extension can have its own language to support patient-friendly terms, local user groups, etc. (see Purpose).

Dependency

A SNOMED CT extension is a set of components and reference set members that add to the SNOMED CT International Edition. An extension is created, structured, maintained and distributed in accordance with SNOMED CT specifications and guidelines. Unlike, the International Edition an extension is not a standalone terminology. The content in an extension depends on the SNOMED CT International Edition, and must be used together with the International Edition and any other extension module on which it depends.

Therefore, a SNOMED CT Extension depends on the SNOMED CT International Edition directly or indirectly through another SNOMED CT Extension (see Extensions).

Versions

A specific version of an extension can be referred to using the date on which the extension was published.

There are many use cases that require a date specific version of an edition, including specifying the substrate of a SNOMED CT query, and specifying the version of SNOMED CT used to code a specific data element in a health record. A versioned edition includes the contents of the specified version of the focus module, plus the contents of all versioned modules on which the versioned focus module depends (as specified in the |Module dependency reference set|). The version of an edition is based on the date on which the edition was released. Many extension providers release their extensions as a versioned edition, using regular and predictable release cycles.

Therefore, a SNOMED CT Extension can be versioned and have a different release cycle than the SNOMED CT International Edition (see Versions).

Characteristics

To summarize, a SNOMED CT Extension has the following characteristics:

• Uses the same RF2 structure as the SNOMED CT International Edition

• Uses a single namespace identifer to globally identify its content

• Uses one or more modules to categorize the content into groups

• Uses one or more languages to support specific user groups and patient-friendly terms

• Depends on the SNOMED CT International Edition

• Uses versions (effective times) to identity its content across multiple releases

Now that we have a clear understanding of what SNOMED CT Extensions are, let's take a look at how can we use them in Snow Owl.

Snow Owl is a multi-purpose terminology server with a main focus on SNOMED CT International Edition and its Extensions. Whether you are a producer of a SNOMED CT Extension or a consumer of one, Snow Owl has you covered. As always, feel free to ask your questions regarding any of the content you read here (raise a ticket on GitHub Issues).

Snow Owl Concepts

Snow Owl uses the following basic concepts to provide authoring and maintenance support for SNOMED CT Extensions.

Code Systems

From the getting started page, we've learned what is a Repository and how Code Systems are defined as part of a Repository.

SNOMED CT Extensions in Snow Owl are basically Code Systems with their own set of properties and characteristics. With Snow Owl's Code System API, a Code System can be created for each SNOMED CT Extension to easily identify the Code System and its components with a single unique identifer, called the Code System short name. The recommended naming approach when selecting the unique short name identifier is the following:

• SNOMED CT International Edition: SNOMEDCT - often included in other editions for distribution purposes

• National Release Center (single maintained extension) - SNOMEDCT-US - represents the SNOMED CT United States of America Extension

• National Release Center (multiple maintained extensions) - SNOMEDCT-UK-CL, SNOMEDCT-UK-DR - United Kingdom Clinical and Drug Extensions, respectively

• Care Provider with a special extension based on a national extension - SNOMEDCT-US-UNMC - University of Nebraska Medical Center's extension builds on top of the SNOMEDCT-US extension

The primary namespace identifer and set of modules and languages can be set during the creation of the Code System, and can be updated later on if required. These properties can be used when users are accessing the terminology server for authoring purposes to provide a seamless authoring experience for the user without them needing to worry about selecting the proper namespace, modules, language tags, etc. (NOTE: this feature is not available yet in the OSS version of Snow Owl)

Extension Of

A Snow Owl Code System can be marked as an extensionOf another Code System, which ties them together, forming a dependency between the two Code Systems. A Code System can have multiple Extension Code Systems, but a Code System can only be extensionOf a single Code System.

Branching

In Snow Owl, a Repository maintains a set of branches and Code Systems are always attached to a dedicated branch. For example, the default root Code Systems are always tied to the default branch, called MAIN. When creating a new Code System, the "working" branchPath can be specified and doing so assigns the branch to the Code System. A Code System cannot be attached to multiple branches at the same time, and a branch can only be assigned to a single Code System in a Repository. Snow Owl's branching infrastructure allows the use of isolated environments for both distribution and authoring workflows, therefore they play crucial role in SNOMED CT Extension managament as well. They also provide the support for seamless upgrade mechanism, which can be done whenever there is a new version available in one of your SNOMED CT Extension's dependent Code Systems.

Versions

As in real life, a Code System can have zero or more versions (or with another name, releases). A version is a special branch that is created during the versioning process and makes the currently available latest content accessible later in its current form. Since SNOMED CT Extensions can have releases as well, creating a Code System Version in Snow Owl is a must in order to produce the release packages.

Examples

The following image shows the repository content rendered from the available commits, after a successful International Edition import.

Dots represent commits made with the commit message on the right. Green boxes represent where the associated branch's HEAD is currently located. Blue tag labels represent versions created during the commit.

If your use case would be to import the SNOMED CT US Extension 2019-09-01 version into this repository, then ideally it would look like this:

The next section describes the use case scenarios in the world of SNOMED CT and the recommended approaches for deploying these scenarios in Snow Owl.

Multi Extension Authoring and Distribution

On top of single Edition/Extension distribution and authoring, Snow Owl provides full support for multi-SNOMED CT distribution and authoring even if the Extensions depend on different versions of the SNOMED CT International Edition.

To achieve a deployment like this you need to perform the same initialization steps for each desired SNOMED CT Extension as if it were a single extension scenario (see single extension). Development and maintenance of each managed extension can happen in parallel without affecting one or the other. Each of them can have their own release cycles, maintenance and upgrade schedules, and so on.

Next steps

After you have initialized your Snow Owl instance with the Extensions you'd like to maintain the next steps are:

• Development

• Release

• Upgrade

• Integrate

A typical extension scenario is the development of the extension itself. Whether you are starting your extension from scratch or already have a well-developed version that you need to maintain, the first choice you need to make is to identify the dependencies of your SNOMED CT Extension.

Extending the International Edition

If your Extension extends the SNOMED CT International Edition directly, then you need to pick one of the available International Edition versions:

• If you are starting from scratch, it is always recommended to select the latest International Release as the starting point of your Extension.

• If you have an existing Extension then you probably already know the International Release version your Extension depends on.

When you have identified the version you need to depend on then you need to import that version (or a later release packages that also includes that version in its FULL RF2 package) first into Snow Owl. Make sure that the createVersion feature of the RF2 import process is enabled, so it will automatically create the versions for each imported RF2 effectiveTime value.

After you have successfully imported all dependencies into Snow Owl, the next step is to create a Code System that represents your SNOMED CT Extension (see Core API). When creating the Code System, besides specifying the namespace and optional modules and languages, you need to enter a Code System shortName, which will serve as the unique identifier of your Extension and select the extensionOf value, which represents the dependency of the Code System.

After you have successfully created the Code System representing your Extension, you can import any existing content from a most recent release or start from scratch by creating the module concept of your extension.

Extending another Extension

If your Extension needs to extend another Extension and not the International Edition itself, then you need to identify the version you'd like to depend on in that Extension (that indirectly will select the International Edition dependency as well). When you have identified all required versions, then starting from the International Edition recursively traverse back and repeat the RF2 Import and Code System creation steps described in the previous section until you have finally imported your extension. In the end your extension might look like this, depending on how many Extensions you are depending on.

Summary

Setting up a Snow Owl deployment like this is not an easy task. It requires a thorough understanding of each SNOMED CT Extension you'd like to import and their dependencies as well. However, after the initial setup, the maintenance of your Extension becomes straightforward, thanks to the clear distinction from the International Edition and from its other dependencies. The release process is easier and you can choose to publish your Extension as an extension only release, or as an Edition or both (see Release). Additionally, when a new version is available in one of the dependencies, you will be able to upgrade your Extension with the help of automated validation rules and upgrade processes (see Upgrade). From the distribution perspective, this scenario shines when you need to maintain multiple Extensions/Editions in a single deployment.

Pros:

• Excellent for authoring and maintenance

• Good for distribution

Cons:

• Harder to set up the initial deployment

The most common use case to consume a SNOMED CT Release Package is to import it directly into a Terminology Server (like Snow Owl) and make it available as read-only content for both human and machine access (via REST and FHIR APIs).

SNOMED CT International Edition

Since Snow Owl by default comes with a pre-initialized SNOMED CT Code System called SNOMEDCT, it is just a single call to import the official RF2 package using the The import by default creates a Code System Version for each SNOMED CT Effective Date available in the supplied RF2 package. After a successful import the content is immediately available via REST and FHIR APIs.

SNOMED CT Extension Edition

Summary

The single edition scenario without much effort provides access to any SNOMED CT Edition directly on the pre-initialized SNOMEDCT Code System. It is easy to set up and maintain. Because of its flat structure, it is good for distribution and extension consumers. Although it can be used for authoring in certain scenarios, due to the missing distinction between the International Edition and the Extension, it is not the best choice for extension authoring and maintenance.

Pros:

• Good for maintaining the SNOMED CT International Edition

• Good for distribution

• Simple to set up and maintain

Cons:

• Not recommended for extension authoring and maintenance

• Not recommended for multi-extension distribution scenarios

Authoring is the process by which content is created in an extension in accordance with a set of authoring principles. These principles ensure the quality of content and referential integrity between content in the extension and content in the International Edition (the principles are set by SNOMED International, can be found here).

During the extension development process authors are:

• creating, modifying or inactivating content according to editorial principles and policies

• running validation processes to verify the quality and integrity of their Extension

• classifying their authored content with an OWL Reasoner to produce its distribution normal form

The authors directly (via the available REST and FHIR APIs) or indirectly (via user interfaces, scripts, etc.) work with the Snow Owl Terminology Server to make the necessary changes for the next planned Extension release.

Workflow and Editing

Authors often require a dedicated editing environment where they can make the necessary changes and let others review the changes they have made, so errors and issues can be corrected before integrating the change with the rest of the Extension. Similarly to how SNOMED CT Extensions are separated from the SNOMED CT International Edition and other dependencies, this can be achieved by using branches.

• Branching API - to create and merge branches

• Compare API - to compare branches

Authoring APIs

To let authors make the necessary changes they need, Snow Owl offers the following SNOMED CT component endpoints to work with:

• Concept API - to create, edit SNOMED CT Concepts

• Description API - to create, edit SNOMED CT Descriptions

• Relationship API - to create, edit SNOMED CT Relationships

• Reference Set API - to create, edit SNOMED CT Reference Sets

• Reference Set Member API - to create, edit SNOMED CT Reference Set Members

Validation

To verify quality and integrity of the changes they have made, authors often generate reports and make further fixes according to the received responses. In Snow Owl, reports and rules can be represented with validation queries and scripts.

• Validation API - to run validation rules and fetch their reported issues on a per branch basis

Classification

Last but not least, authors run an OWL Reasoner to classify their changes and generate the necessary normal form of their Extension. The Classification API provides support for running these reasoner instances and generating the necessary normal form.

Maintenance of a SNOMED CT Extension is essential to ensure that

• it incorporates changes requested by terminology consumers

• it remains aligned with the SNOMED CT International Edition

While both of these maintenance related tasks are potentially assigned to one of the upcoming Extension development cycles, there is a clear distinction between the two maintenance tasks.

Change requests

Changes requested by your terminology consumers are typically content authoring tasks that you would assign to an Extension authoring team. They usually come with a well-described problem you need to address in the terminology as you would do in the usual development cycle.

See the Extension Development section on how you can address change requests and incorporate them as regular tasks into the main version of your Extension.

International Edition Changes

Aligning content to the SNOMED CT International Edition is one of the main responsibilities of an Extension maintainer. However, keeping up with the changes introduced in SNOMED CT International Edition biannually (on January 31st and July 31st) can be an overwhelming task, especially if:

• you are under pressure from your terminology consumers to make the requested changes ASAP, especially in mission critical scenarios.

• the changes introduced in the International Edition are conflicting with your local changes and/or causing maintenance related issues after the upgrade.

To address SNOMED CT International Edition upgrade tasks in a reliable and reproducible way, Snow Owl offers an upgrade flow for SNOMED CT Extensions.

Upgrades

A Code System upgrade in Snow Owl is a complex workflow with states and steps. The workflow involves a special Upgrade Code System, a series of automated migration processes and validation rules to ensure the quality and reliability of the operation. The upgrade can be done quickly if there were no conflicts between the Extension and the International Edition. However, updates can also be a long-running process spanning over many months when significant structural changes (e.g. in substances, anatomy, or modeling approach) are made in the International Edition.

Starting the Upgrade

In Snow Owl, SNOMED CT Extension are linked to their SNOMED CT dependency with the extensionOf property. This property describes the International Edition and its version that the Extension depends on. For example, the SNOMEDCT/2019-07-31 value specifies that our Extension depends on the 2019-07-31 version of the International Edition.

Extension upgrades can be started when there is a new version available in the Extension/Edition we have selected as our dependency in the extensionOf property. When fetching a SNOMED CT Code System via the Code System API, Snow Owl will check if there are any upgrades availables and return them in the availableUpdates array property. If there are no upgrades available the array will be empty.

To start an Extension upgrade to a newer International Edition (or to a newer Extension dependency version), you can use the Upgrade API. The only thing that needs to be specified there is the desired new version of the Extension's extensionOf dependency.

When the upgrade is started, Snow Owl creates a special <codeSystemShortName>-UP-<newExtensionOf> (eg. SNOMEDCT-MYEXT-UP-SNOMEDCT-2020-01-31) Code System to allow authors and the automated processes to migrate the latest development version of the Extension to the new dependency.

Regular Maintenance

Regular daily Extension development tasks still need to be resolved and pushed somewhere in order to continue the development of the Extension, even if an upgrade process is in progress. Each Extension still has an active development version, even if an upgrade is in progress, which can be used to push daily maintenance changes and business as usual tasks.

Changes pushed to the development area will regularly need to be synced with the upgrade until the upgrade completes, so the upgrade team will be able to resolve all remaining conflicts and issues.

Upgrade Checks

Upgrade Checks ensure the quality of the upgrade process and execute certain tasks/checks automatically. An Upgrade Check can be any logic or function to be run during the upgrade. Upgrade Checks can access the underlying upgrade Code System's content and report any issues (validation rules) or fix content automatically (migration rules). For example, a validation rule (like Active relationships must have active source, type, destination references) can be executed after each change pushed to the upgrade branch to verify whether there is any potentially invalid relationship left to fix or you are ready to go.

Completing the Upgrade

Once the upgrade authoring team is done with the necessary changes to align the Extension with the new International Edition and all the checks are completed successfully the upgrade can be completed. Completing the upgrade performs the following steps:

• Creates a <codeSystemShortName>-DO-<previousExtensionOf> Code System to refer to the previous state of the Extension

• Changes the current working branch of the Extension Code System to the branch that was used during the upgrade process

• Deletes the <codeSystemShortName>-UP-<newExtensionOf> Code System, which marks the upgrade complete, and the upgrade itself cannot be accessed anymore.

When an Extension reaches the end of its current development cycle, it needs to be prepared for release and distribution.

Workflows and Authoring Branches

All planned content changes that are still on their dedicated branch either need to be integrated with the main development version or removed from the scope of the next release.

Prepare the Release

After all development branches have been merged and integrated with the main work-in-progress version, the Extension needs to be prepared for release. This usually involves last minute fixes, running quality checks and validation rules and generating the final necessary normal form of the Extension.

Release

When all necessary steps have been performed successfully, a new Code System Version needs to be created in Snow Owl to represent the latest release. The versioning process will assign the requested effectiveTime to all unpublished components, update the necessary Metadata reference sets (like the Module Dependency Reference Set) and finally create a version branch to reference this release later.

Packaging

After a successful release, an RF2 Release Package needs to be generated for downstream consumers of your Extension. Snow Owl can generate this final RF2 Release Packages for the newly released version via the RF2 Export API.